CMS: Hybrid, Decoupled, Headless, or Clueless
Category : Content Management Systems
Content management systems (CMS) are as ubiquitous as food carts in major cities. Most of them find a niche to survive. We have many flavors of CMS. Depending on your needs, implementing a CMS solution can be trivial to more complex.
The traditional CMSs that added API capabilities are called the hybrid. The new ones that built their delivery mechanism separate from the backend system are called the decoupled. The ones with API as primary interaction mechanism are called the headless. Headless stands for anything that doesn’t use a graphical user interface for user interaction. The term headless has been around well before it became a buzzword in CMSs. Software applications such as word processors, pdf generators, image processors and browsers have long been used in headless mode by developers.
What Choices Do We Have?
Let’s start with the headless buzzword. A quick search for headless CMS brings up one interesting article in CMS Wire that explains a couple dozen players. The URL for the article starts as 13-headless-cms but goes on to list 24 of them. This is not an exhaustive list. There are many more CMSs and digital experience platforms that provide hybrid and decoupled platforms as well. A few of them include Episerver, Adobe Experience Cloud, Sitecore, Crafter CMS, Liferay, and Jahia. We also have many more PHP based solutions such as Drupal and others.
The other major CMS in terms of market share is WordPress. There are more sites built on WordPress than any other single platform. Organizations of all sizes use them somewhere or the other. WordPress also has REST API that could be leveraged to create single page applications and deliver content to various devices. WordPress could be considered as a hybrid CMS with the API capabilities. Jetpack provides security, backup and performance on top of standard wordpress installation.
The concept behind headless, hybrid and distributed are not new. CMSs have provided these capabilities for a long time. These terms have become the buzzword as we are moving into the fourth industrial revolution with connected devices.
How Do You Choose?
There are many factors that come into play when it comes to choosing a CMS. The basic requirement is that it has a robust way to create and deliver contents of various types. In addition, we could look into the following listed reasons:
What are you building? Answering this question will help choose the appropriate CMS. In a startup economy, not everyone needs a complex system with a high price tag. Also, not all sites need all the capabilities. Based on your need you can definitely find the one that suits with price tags from a few dollars a month to thousands of dollars a month. More and more vendors are supporting businesses of all sizes with their SaaS offerings and pricing model.
Developers who are already into a certain ecosystem such as Firebase may want to go with something like Flamelink that is already built and billed for such environments. Those who are using Heroku may want to start using something like Butter CMS or Elegant CMS as these vendors target that niche. A more robust enterprise implementation may want to focus on enterprise scale systems that have both self-hosted and cloud solution (SaaS).
3. Content Delivery / Caching
Speed and distribution are basic requirements for all CMS solutions. Deployment and delivery also depends on what you are building and where your audiences are located. Are you trying to build a site/app for a museum, a sports site, a news media, or an intranet for distributed workforce around the world? It is easy to distribute static assets that are publicly accessible to various channels and regions. Assets that require permissioning needs advanced capabilities and may benefit from distributed decoupled CMS.
4. Security and Audience Targeting
When it comes to users and roles a lot of these systems focus on content creators and not content consumers. If you are building a site for the general public, the only access control that you may need is for authoring, editing, and publishing contents. Once the contents are published they are public and often have no restrictions on who can view them.
If you have highly permissioned, sensitive contents with targeted audience a better choice is to look into digital experience platforms that offer a hybrid/decoupled model along with all the enterprise features.
5. Robust Search
Robust search capabilities backed by search engines such as Elastic or Solr are key requirements for most major implementations. The search needs to be powered by strong support for taxonomy and permission models.
6. Whom are they Competing with?
Another way to identify the capabilities of the CMS is to look at whom they are competing against. Are they claiming themselves to be better than WordPress, Drupal or other enterprise vendors? This can give you an idea, especially when you are not familiar with the product that you are looking into.
Cost is always going to be a major factor when choosing a product. As an example, Butter CMS focuses on a number of blog posts to determine the pricing. This may not be a great pricing option to build a public blogging platform. Some platforms may require thousands of dollars per month in investment which may include subscription, licensing, and development costs. The amount of money an organization spends often depends on the size of the budget. It does not always correlate with the need unless they are employing lean methodologies.
8. Find Out Who Uses These CMSs
This is a little tricky one. Many vendors may list the same customer as their client. In large organizations, different departments tend to have their own procurement processes. It is possible that a large company may have multiple solutions across various departments and locations. It is also possible that the listed customer was once a client of the vendor but not anymore.
If you are planning on a major implementation, support is a very key factor. The sales team often goes away once you make the purchase. How do we know if a vendor has a good support service? It could be a challenge to get unbiased opinions from references. It may help to talk to other customers at conferences, roadshows or by directly reaching out to them to understand their experience. The happiness level of employees are also indicators of company culture. Don’t hesitate to look at Glassdoor reviews.
10. A Trusted Partner
Any major implementation needs a trusted partner. A partner does not have to be a major firm. It could one or two people who have the expertise to sort through the pile. It is key that you are able to look beyond the buzz and hype.
Identify your need. Identify your budget. Identify a few vendors using some or all of the capabilities listed above. If the product is an open source, download and see the capabilities for yourself. If it is not an open source, ask for a trial. Build a quick proof of concept. Choose the one that meets your criteria. If your team is committed and happy with the choice, that is a sign of a great beginning.
Published: July 25, 2019